Exploring the Differences: Scotts vs. Vigoro Mulch scotts vs vigoro mulch

Ingredients and Quality scotts vs vigoro mulch

Scotts and Vigoro mulches are both used as covering layers for protecting plants and soil. Scotts mulch typically consists of natural materials such as wood chips, leaves, and other organic matter, along with some protective additives. In comparison, Vigoro mulch also includes natural materials, but the composition may vary depending on the product type. In terms of quality, Scotts is generally considered a high-quality brand, offering reliable covering effects and protection. However, Vigoro’s product quality also varies depending on the product type and composition, with some products being comparable to Scotts while others may be slightly inferior.

Color and Appearance

Scotts and Vigoro mulches offer a variety of color and appearance options to meet different users’ needs. Scotts mulch typically provides more natural colors such as brown or black, which helps blend with plants and landscapes. Vigoro mulches also offer similar color choices but may include some more diverse options such as red or gold. In terms of appearance, both Scotts and Vigoro mulches provide even coverage for plant surfaces, enhancing soil moisture retention and protection, and contributing to overall landscape beautification.

Protective Effectiveness and Durability

Both Scotts and Vigoro mulches have protective effects on plant growth and soil moisture retention. They reduce water evaporation from the soil surface, prevent weed growth, and maintain stable soil temperatures, thus providing a conducive growth environment. In terms of durability, Scotts products generally have a longer lifespan, maintaining their covering effects and protection for a longer period. Vigoro mulches also offer similar durability, but this depends on the product type and usage conditions.

Price and Value

In terms of price, Scotts and Vigoro mulches have different pricing strategies depending on factors such as product type, packaging size, and distribution channels. Generally, Scotts products may be slightly higher-end, but they usually offer more reliable and durable effects, providing better value for money. In comparison, Vigoro mulches may be more competitively priced, but some products may lag behind in terms of quality and durability. Therefore, when choosing a product, users need to consider a balance between price and value.

User Reviews and Reputation

Based on user reviews and reputation, both Scotts and Vigoro mulches have a certain level of popularity and recognition in the market. Scotts products are typically well-received by users, being considered a reliable brand that provides high-quality covering effects and protection. Vigoro products also have a loyal user base, but there are also some doubts about their quality and performance among users. Taking into account user reviews and reputation, users can choose the most suitable mulch brand based on their needs and preferences.

Reviewed in the United States on October 15, 2023

Verified Purchase

I live in the country so taking care of my lawn is not a high priority. I do not believe it watering a lawn and cut only when it needs to be cut. I am all about low maintenance when it comes to lawn care.

That said now and then repairs are needed and having a good an easy to use dependable seed and one that grows in sun or shade, is a must for me. I have tried a number of different types of seed over the years and came across this brand and mix at a local hardware store and it seemed to work out very well for those occasional repairs and patching projects. It grows fast and fills in pretty thick which helps keep weeds at bay in new areas and over-seeding in the fall seems to help choke out weeds in the spring before they get a chance to take root – for the most part anyway.

The summer of 2021 I started to take back up golfing and I practice in my back yard which is about an acre. When using irons it is typical to take a divot which, if you hit as many balls as I do, sometimes 200+ a session, can do some serous damage to your lawn over time. To fix these areas I started using the Scotts Turf Builder Sun and Shade Mix. I decided to create a large area, about 1800 sq ft to use just for practicing. The idea being to practice in one spot then repairing that spot after practice is done and moving to an adjacent spot. I researched the type of seed used for fairways on golf courses and this mix is about the same and seems to work really well. The area varies in the amount of sun and shade and this mix works well in that regard too.

I have tried a few methods to do repairs. I tried raking with a stiff rake to loosen the soil then sprinkling the seeds on top and re-raking it with a leaf rake to spread the seed evenly which worked fine, but I found that when watering it’s too easy to wash the seeds from one area creating spotty growth. It does fill in eventually, but I wanted a method that would be quicker and guarantee even growth.

What seems to work best is to fill any deep holes with soil, put down a soil/seed mix, then cover it a small layer of soil to help retain the moisture and tap it down lightly with my foot. I keep a bucket with
a mix of top soil and sand and another with a top soil+sand+seed mix that I use just for this purpose. I water two to three times a day with a hose or watering can with a sprinkler head. This method also works well to repair any urine spots my dog makes. It does require flushing the spot real good with water and baking soda first to lower the acidity of the soil.

I cut this area with a push reel mower which allows me to cut it real low. Which is another plus to this blend in that it can be cut very low without any problems. However, I normally keep it a little longer in new areas so not to stress the new growth.

Since the area is so large area I decided to buy the seed in a larger quantity (20 lb) and found it on Amazon for a real good price. I ended up getting a second bag so I could over seed the area before winter. When over-seeding, I normally just spread it by hand although I have used a hand held spreader too. This worked very well and I was amazed at how dense it was in the spring.

Overall I am very pleased with this seed. It is very easy to use, requires minimal maintenance and looks great. If you are looking for a low maintenance seed that is easy to use and grows quickly in sun or shade this will work very well.

95 people found this helpful